16 September COMMENT: LONDON — Ousted South African finance minister Pravin Gordhan has refused to accept KPMG’s apology – and is talking to his lawyers to ensure proper satisfaction is extracted from the Gupta auditors. In a powerful statement released yesterday shortly after KPMG fired eight SA execs including the CEO (see below), Gordhan says the apology is far too little and much too late. At Biznews we share his view. Like Bell Pottinger, KPMG has underestimated the anger among South Africans over its role in facilitating the plundering of national resources by the Indian immigrant Gupta family. Citizens are no longer swallowing the deeply complicit president Jacob Zuma’s trumped up claim that whites are to blame for all SA’s ills. For his part, Gordhan says KPMG’s apology would only be taken seriously if it were to show proper contrition. He suggests part of the way would be to create an anti-corruption unit to employ all of those who lost their jobs at SA Revenue Services as a result of a contrived R23m hatchet job which KPMG has now recanted. In effect, KPMG accepted a bribe to produce a report used by the Zuptoids at SARS to knife Gordhan and fire dozens of corruption fighting SARS executives whose only crime was that they acted with integrity. What Andersen did at Enron pales by comparison. And we all know how that ended up. – Alec Hogg
By Pravin Gordhan
Although I welcome the withdrawal of the KPMG “SARS” report, I am surprised by the scant regard shown for their role in the “capture” of the revenue service and the huge damage that it has done to the livelihoods and reputations of a very professional, honest and loyal group of public servants. It is unfortunate that a company with the stature of KPMG, with a responsibility and obligation to be objective, has been found to be wanting. This is exacerbated by their collaboration with the Gupta family.
So let me categorically state, that which KPMG ought to have had the integrity and honesty to state:
– The Research and Investigative unit created in the South African Revenue Service (SARS) was legal.
– Its activities in detecting and combatting the illicit tobacco trade and other efforts aimed at bringing an end to tax evasion, were within the law.
– KPMG had no basis, except subservience to a malicious SARS management, to malign a number of individuals and facilitate, I repeat, the capture of a vital state institution.
The witting and over-enthusiastic collaboration of senior KPMG personnel (whether in current employment at KPMG or not) and their collusion with nefarious characters in SARS, in fact directly contributed to “state capture” and gave legitimacy to the victimization of good, honest professionals and managers. It should and must be remembered that this was about attacking SARS as an institution with the main intention being to capture it.
These are the symptoms of deteriorating levels of governance and the gravity of state capture. The saddest consequences about this is the negative impact it has had on the lives of all those that were and continue to be persecuted – if the latest actions of the Hawks and NPA are anything to go by.
KPMG international did not implement its own criticism of KPMG South Africa – that those affected by their alleged findings should be given a hearing. Did they talk or even attempt to contact the senior officials who were victimized at SARS? Why has there been no direct contact with myself, to convey a sincere apology? This is typical colonial arrogance and KPMG has not done enough. One would have expected KPMG to have the courage to admit, in the face of their own investigation, that the establishment of this unit was in fact legal. This option still remains open to them.
I note their “regret” but doubt whether this is adequate and proportional to the damage that KPMG has done. I will be seeking legal advice in this regard. Whilst there has been personal consequences the real issue that confronts us is the significant damage to our hard won democracy, to our state institutions and ultimately to the South African people for whom we seek a better life.
South Africa has been severely affected by the ills of state capture, and by the individuals and institutions that either enable or seek to implement it.
This may be a small step in the right direction to hold corporates accountable for their wrong doings as well as the beginning of what reparations will be to make things right. KPMG has a lot more to do to convince South Africans that they will undergo a genuine change in culture and ethics and are prepared to take total ownership for the damage they have caused or contributed to.
If they are truly remorseful they must provide equivalent employment to Ivan Pillay and others as a corruption fighting unit within KPMG itself.
To South Africans, I say take strength in your collective action to hold accountable, all those responsible for the demise of the quality of our democracy and the decimation of state institutions.