The world is changing fast and to keep up you need local knowledge with global context.
JOHANNESBURG — Hospital operator Netcare is exiting the UK market amid rental cost pressures and challenges with NHS. It’s a big story as certain external factors have driven Netcare to see no other option. However, in the note below, Netcare says its South African business is still ticking over strongly. What’s concerning, though, is that South Africa is looking to implement NHI, its answer to NHS. – Gareth van Zyl
Netcare media statement:
Strategic decision the result of inability to negotiate lower rentals in the UK
Netcare Limited, South Africa’s largest private hospital and emergency medical services operator, has announced a strategic decision to exit the United Kingdom (UK) market. Netcare will be initiating a process to dispose of its interests in General Healthcare Group (GHG).
Netcare acquired GHG in May 2006 as part of a consortium. Shortly after the acquisition, GHG was restructured into an operating company (BMI Healthcare) and a series of property companies (collectively “PropCo”) that held the hospital properties and leased them to BMI Healthcare under long-term leases.
Netcare has spent considerable time and resources pursuing a rent reduction transaction with BMI Healthcare’s largest landlord on 35 of its 59 hospital properties. However, after more than five years of negotiation, Netcare has concluded that it is highly unlikely that it will be able to conclude a rent reduction transaction under which the UK business will have the resources necessary for ongoing investment to allow BMI Healthcare to remain competitive and simultaneously generate an appropriate risk-adjusted return commensurate with the rest of the Netcare group’s businesses.
“When these UK lease arrangements were concluded”, said Dr Richard Friedland, Netcare CEO, “they were considered market-related and provided for a fixed escalation in rent of 2.5% per annum. However, following the global financial crisis of 2008, the accompanying declining private medical insurance (PMI) demand, and the sustained period of exceptionally low inflation in recent years, BMI Healthcare’s rent obligations have grown to be unaffordable.
Netcare to sell UK operations. They never performed dragged down by onerous rentals, dramatic cost cutting by government and private sector and move to day care. Share up sharply now That just a S.A. operation. S.A. results good
— Wayne McCurrie (@WayneMcCurrie) March 28, 2018
“The continued escalation in rent is unsustainable. In 2017, rental costs represented approximately 20% of UK revenue and this is a drain on capital which BMI Healthcare otherwise needs for ongoing and future investment,” says Friedland. This circumstance is not dissimilar to other businesses in the UK where rent obligations have become onerous.
“The UK healthcare market has changed fundamentally since Netcare acquired GHG in 2006 as a result primarily of the global financial crisis and recession that followed. This substantially eroded demand for private medical insurance in the UK. This was partially compensated by the increasing number of NHS patients treated in the private sector at lower tariffs. Recently however, and particularly since 2017, NHS demand management interventions to reduce elective surgery have impacted all providers.
Netcare will exit the UK, 12 years after buying half of General Healthcare Group for £2.2 billion (then R24 billion). What a messy, ill-conceived distraction. #EmpireBuildingGoneWrong
— Hilton Tarrant (@hiltontarrant) March 28, 2018
These pricing pressures have required the business to respond and implement efficiency measures. BMI has successfully done so over the last few years, but it is now critical that this large fixed rental cost be corrected as market conditions in the UK are expected to remain challenging in the medium to long term” added Friedland.
Netcare has previously indicated that it would not invest further capital into BMI Healthcare in the absence of a rent reduction transaction.
Furthermore, the short-term funding solution concluded with BMI Healthcare’s lenders in December 2017 expires on 31 March 2018. The lenders have conditioned any further short-term funding on existing GHG shareholders relinquishing effective control of the boards of directors of BMI Healthcare. Netcare has agreed, in the interests of the business, to accede to this demand. This has allowed BMI Healthcare to conclude a further short-term funding arrangement with its lenders and it will continue to pursue a longer-term funding arrangement.
Netcare has always ring-fenced its respective businesses in SA and the UK. As such, the debt obligations of BMI Healthcare and those of PropCo do not have recourse to Netcare and its South African operations.
“Just as our investment in the UK market made good sense at the time, so too we believe that the decision to exit that market is in the best interests of Netcare shareholders.
“Netcare’s business model in South Africa remains sound, and we’re expecting good growth in profitability in this financial year from the SA operations,” says Friedland. “As announced earlier in March, Netcare is delighted with the successful acquisition of Akeso Clinics in South Africa, with the addition of 12 dedicated mental healthcare facilities providing Netcare with an excellent and established platform from which to expand its mental health offering and contribute to the future growth of the Group.”
Cyril Ramaphosa: The Audio Biography
Listen to the story of Cyril Ramaphosa's rise to presidential power, narrated by our very own Alec Hogg.