Will mass protests and a secret ballot persuade ANC MPs to jump?

Flag map of South Africa

If South Africans are belatedly waking up to the breath-taking extent of State Capture by Zuma and his Zuptoids, imagine how jolted from mindless tradition and proportional representation numbness the until-now party-line-towing ANC MPs are feelingANC Chief Whip Jackson Mthembu faces his stiffest-ever test in cracking the sjambok/ dangling the carrot ahead of Tuesday’s No Confidence debate. His MPs must, like slowly-boiled frogs, surely be shocked awake by the unexpectedly cold splash of civic outrage against their leader – something unprecedented in their party’s history? It’s a splendid irony that Msholozi will today celebrate his 75th birthday in Kliptown surrounded by beneficiaries/ acolytes while Sipho Pityana, an ANC stalwart-turned-Save-SA chief leads a second major march on the Union Buildings. Behind the scenes, a critical development is taking place. The Constitutional Court has just granted the UDM permission to have its application to have the No Confidence vote declared secret, heard. Should they succeed, ANC MPs may take their chances with Zuma’s spies and vote with the opposition. Will the required 50 cause a palace revolution and unseat Zuma? Unlikely – but he’ll shift uncomfortably on his throne. Pityana, like former President Thabo Mbeki, is reminding MPs that Constitutionally, they represent the people and not their party, and should thus vote with their consciences. In an open letter to ANC MPs (below), he reminds them that their leader has already flouted his Constitutional obligation to South Africa’s people by appointing a slavish cabinet, firing competent ministers without logical reason and capturing the Treasury. By flouting their own constitutional duty they’d perpetuate misrule and defy the wiser, cooler heads in their leadership cadre, plus key elements of the Alliance. The tipping point will come when enough ANC MPs believe there’s a critical mass of populist resistance against their leader. Whether that arrives before Tuesday is an open question. – Chris Bateman

Thousands to march against Zuma on his birthday

By Tshidi Madia, News24

Johannesburg – As the ANC prepares to celebrate President Jacob Zuma’s 75th birthday, opposition parties will be leading thousands in protest to demand that he step down as South Africa’s citizen number one.

Thousands, including members of opposition parties and civil organisations, are expected to march from Church Square in Pretoria to the Union Buildings.

Jacob Zuma, South Africa’s president, attends the launch of a new trans Africa locomotive at the Transnet SOC Ltd. engineering site in Pretoria, South Africa, on Tuesday, April 4, 2017. Zuma’s shock decision to fire his finance minister and stack his cabinet with loyalists may have seemed like good politics, but it’s led to an immediate downgrade of the nation’s credit rating by S&P Global Ratings that will cost an already moribund economy dearly. Photographer: Waldo Swiegers/Bloomberg

Last week thousands of South Africans marched and held pickets in order to demonstrate their dissatisfaction with Zuma as the country’s president.

The rallies were sparked by Zuma’s decision to fire Pravin Gordhan as his finance minister. In the days following his Cabinet reshuffle three of the ANC’s top six claimed there was no consultation with the party over the decision, with ANC secretary general Gwede Mantashe claiming that the list of new ministers and their deputies was compiled elsewhere.

South Africa has also been downgraded to junk status by two credit ratings agencies since Zuma announced the changes, with some economists fearing that the country is headed for another downgrade.


The president has been dogged by allegations that his close associates, the Gupta family, have undue influence over state-owned enterprises and certain key decisions he has made, including the hiring and firing of members of the national executive.

MPs urged to vote with conscience

The wave of protests comes on the back of a pending motion of no confidence debate against Zuma in the National Assembly, with opposition parties calling for ANC MPs to vote with their conscience and not according to the party line.

Former President Thabo Mbeki has also joined the call to the MPs. In a letter published in The Star he urged the MPs to place the people of the country above what the ANC has asked them to do.

File Photo: Thabo Mbeki speaks with Jacob Zuma at the African National Congress conference in Polokwane, South Africa, on Monday, Dec. 17, 2007. Photographer: Greg Marinovich/Bloomberg News

On Tuesday while opposition parties mobilised people to join in their mass demonstration, the Constitutional Court granted the UDM access to the court for an application to allow a secret ballot to be used in the motion of no confidence against Zuma.

Save South Africa, which hosted a march last week, announced on Tuesday that it would join the opposition parties in their demonstration against the president.

Police Minister Fikile Mbalula said that violence during the National Day of Action would not be tolerated.

“We call upon protest organisers to ensure that the protest actions are peaceful and do not infringe on the rights of others. Intimidation of South Africans who choose not to join the protest will not be tolerated,” he said during a media briefing on Tuesday.

Several roads in Pretoria will be affected by the march which is expected to take place between 09:00 and 16:00. These include Madiba, Lillian Ngoyi, Sisulu, Du Toit, Nelson Mandela Drive, Edmond, Hamilton and Thabo Sehume. Tshwane metro said Madiba, Edmond and Hamilton will be completely closed off.

Call for solidarity

There has been no confirmation of whether or not an official will accept the memorandum of demands from those marching to the Union Buildings. Attempts to get comment from the Presidency have gone unanswered, but the president will most likely not be there as he is expected to join members of the ANC in Kliptown, Johannesburg, to celebrate his birthday.

ANC logo stencilled on a wall in Soweto, Johannesburg

One of his loyalists, ANC Youth League president Collen Maine, said he had no interest in the march as he would be participating in the birthday celebrations. However, he warned that the league would lead its own twenty-thousand-capacity march soon.

Reacting to the march, the ANC said those marching against Zuma were well within their constitutional rights.

“This is but one of the mechanisms in our society to deal with and resolve conflict. Others include the constitutional right to call for a motion of no confidence in the president of the republic, such as the one that shall be debated next week,” said ANC head of communications Khusela Sangoni.

“We are of the view that there should never be any need for anyone to be alarmist but rather appreciate our maturing and strengthening democracy which allows us to ventilate our differing views and opinions on issues of the day,” she added.

Meanwhile, opposition parties have also urged those outside of Gauteng to show their contempt about Zuma’s continued stay at the country’s helm.

“The people outside Gauteng who can’t make it to the march, they must pick busy streets with homemade placards, stand in solidarity and demand for Zuma to step down,” said EFF spokesperson Mbuyiseni Ndlozi.

From Save SA’s Sipho Pityana

An open letter to ANC members of Parliament

Today, I will be joining leaders of parties from across the political spectrum in a march on the Union Buildings to demand that President Jacob Zuma must get out of office.

All parties with representation in Parliament will be there – except, of course, my own beloved African National Congress.

Save SA convenor Sipho Pityana

It’s a strange feeling, to be marching against the President of my own organisation. Ironically, I do so out of loyalty to the values and principles of an ANC that has been my political home for over 40 years. Importantly, I do so for the undying love for my country and its beautiful people.

In the 1970s, I was among those student activists who led protests in Port Elizabeth against the deadly apartheid regime of John Vorster. I dared to defy the system and took part in unregistered trade union and civic activity that culminated in what subsequently became Cosatu and Sanco.

In the 1980s, I marched alongside fellow exiles in many parts of the world, deployed by both the ANC and SACTU in our international programmes, against the apartheid regime’s PW Botha and subsequently FW de Klerk.

In the 1990s, I marched alongside my fellow liberated South Africans in Pretoria in support of our newly-elected democratic president, Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela.

And now here I am, marching through Pretoria again – this time, marching against our own President, Jacob Gedleyihlekisa Zuma. And I’m doing so for the second time in one week.

It’s a decision that didn’t come lightly.

At times, I’m sure today’s march may create an uncomfortable feeling – much, I suspect, like the one you feel as an ANC MP when confronted by growing calls for you to vote in favour of a vote of no confidence in the President later this month.

Why, then, as a member of the ANC am I marching against my own President? As a loyal member of the movement, why am I siding with political opponents to protest against my own President? And why should you do the right thing in Parliament and vote against your own President?

For me, there’s a stark choice between my country and a President who threatens everything that inspired me and many others to be part of a journey in the struggle for our freedom. Joining this march is a clear choice; my country comes first. I implore you to make a similar choice, which I have no doubt you will.

There’s a clear constitutional argument as to why you can and should vote in support of the motion of no confidence:

  • When you became a Member of Parliament, you solemnly declared that you would “be faithful to the Republic of South Africa and will obey, respect and uphold the Constitution and all other laws of the Republic”.
  • Neither the Constitution of South Africa nor the constitution of the ANC require you as an MP to hold your party allegiance above that of the Constitution and the people of South Africa.
  • The ANC constitution regulates the conduct of ANC members in your capacity as members of the ANC — and not in your capacity as Members of Parliament. Therefore, Honourable Member, although you became a Member of Parliament by virtue of your ANC membership, you are in Parliament to represent the people of South Africa. Honour them!
  • For this reason your loyalty, as a Member of Parliament, lies with the Constitution of South Africa and its people. As such the country, South Africa, must trump your loyalty to anything else — especially to President Zuma.

But let’s talk about that President.

As you are no doubt aware, the Constitutional Court has found that Zuma “…failed to uphold, defend, and respect the Constitution as supreme law of the land”. In the same judgment, the Court stated that the National Assembly “…bears the responsibility to play an oversight role over the executive and State Organs and ensure that Constitutional obligations are properly executed.” and “is duty-bound to hold the President accountable…”

It also found that “failure by the National Assembly to hold the President accountable by ensuring that he complies … is inconsistent with its obligation to scrutinise and oversee executive action and to maintain an oversight of the exercise of executive powers by the President.”

Constitutional Court of South Africa.

And then there’s the President’s so-called “constitutional prerogatives”.

In terms of Section 91(2) of the Constitution, the President has the power to appoint the Deputy President, Ministers and Deputy Ministers. Therefore, as shown recently, the President exercises this power not as a member of the ANC, but as the President of the Republic. He refers to this as his constitutional prerogative.

Section 89 of the Constitution empowers the National Assembly to remove the President. In addition, in terms of section 102 of the Constitution, the National Assembly is empowered to pass a vote of no confidence on the President.

Like the President, when exercising those powers you do so as an MP — and not as a member of the ANC. As such you have the prerogative to decide on the fate of the President, just like the President has the prerogative to decide on the fate of his Cabinet.

This means, Honourable Member, that you should not allow your membership of the ANC to be confused with that of Parliament. And when you vote on 18 April, you should do so in the best interests of your country.

But there is a moral argument in support of this, too.

Day by day, more evidence emerges that Jacob Zuma is not fit to be President of this Republic. His recent actions have made it abundantly clear that he no longer even represents the interests of the ANC, never mind the country as a whole.

He now embodies the greatest possible threat to our democracy and, to paraphrase Secretary General Gwede Mantashe, has succeeded in dividing the ANC in a way that even the apartheid regime found impossible to achieve.

South African Parliament building with Louis Botha statue, Cape Town.

In this, the year of Comrade OR Tambo, it would the greatest tragedy if we were to allow false talk of “unity” to result in us sitting passively on the sidelines while our Movement, our country and its people, and the entire democratic project are captured and subverted.

There is a long history to Zuma’s betrayal of the ANC and South Africa. But the brutal, inescapable truth is that his Cabinet reshuffle in the early hours of 31 March 2017 will be remembered as the day he finally sold his soul to forces outside the ANC.

This leaves us with no choice but to act, and to act decisively

Many other progressive forces have already expressed their deep concern at Zuma’s current trajectory, as have individuals inside the Top Six and key elements of the Alliance – not to mention the massive groundswell within civil society and other sectors.

Their concern is now translating into action and, as leaders in society and in the ANC, it is incumbent upon you to provide leadership in terms of the role and character of that action.

Honourable Member, you will be judged by history in terms of how you vote during the motion of no confidence.

You can either vote to protect Zuma and entrench his misrule – and in so doing, contribute to the slow death of the ANC and unquestionable lasting damage to our country.

Or you can use your power, the power of your vote, to rid the Movement, and South Africa, of this evil man.

It is not an easy decision. Many of us understand that it goes against “tradition”, and possibly the instruction of the Chief Whip, to support our political opponents.

But there comes a time when we have to do the right thing. And the vote of no confidence is just that day.

Let these words of Oliver Tambo ring through your mind as you reflect on your critical decision: “You might think it is difficult to wage a liberation struggle,” he said. “Wait until you are in power. At that stage you will realise it is actually more difficult to keep power than to wage a liberation war. Be prepared to learn from other people’s revolutions. Learn from the enemy also. The enemy is not necessarily doing everything wrong.”

Yours comradely

Sipho M Pityana

  • Sipho Pityana is convenor of the Save South Africa campaign. 
(Visited 20 times, 1 visits today)