New farm law to block foreign land ownership: Another ANC move to shut out whites?

ANC logo stencilled on a wall in Soweto, Johannesburg

Who is a foreigner? Someone who was born and has always lived outside South Africa? Or is it a South African with another passport, for example a South African who spends much of his or her time living elsewhere to minimise South African tax liabilities? Can the many foreign-born residents, whether they originate from Zambia or Germany, who have invested in agricultural businesses be considered foreign? Those are the types of questions that are likely to be discussed as the ANC tries to take its plans to redistribute land to the next level. Foreigners will be expected to sell up to ensure that they don’t own too much property. There have been growing calls to expropriate land from white people, with President Jacob Zuma among those making populist noises. The reality is that land redistribution is messy, with attempts so far to get more land into black hands failing to make a meaningful impact to economic growth. As Professor of Sociology Monty Roodt, Rhodes University, noted recently: research on the impact of land reform has largely concluded that it has contributed little to helping beneficiaries earn a livelihood from the land. The reasons for this include inadequate post-settlement support, lack of skills, poor planning and infighting within communities, he has pointed out. However, dry discussions about post-settlement support won’t sway the crowds as the ANC moves towards contesting the next elections. With only a month to submit comments on the bill, expect the political rhetoric to focus on easy gains for future black beneficiaries as the ANC pushes its agenda. – Jackie Cameron

By Matthew le Cordeur

Cape Town – Rural Development and Land Reform Minister Gugile Nkwinti published the Regulation of Agricultural Land Holdings Bill on Friday, giving stakeholders until April 16 to submit comments.

If promulgated as an act, the law will ban foreigners from buying agricultural land and require them to enter into long-term leases.

Foreigners selling land would also have to offer the minister “the right of first refusal to acquire ownership of such agricultural land holdings”, Nkwinti explains in the gazetted bill.

Minister of Rural Development and Land Reform Gugile Nkwinti and Minister of Economic Development Ebrahim Patel during the media briefing on the progress made on the government and construction settlements agreement signed in 2016.
The bill will see the creation of a Land Commission, which will oversee the collection and dissemination of all information regarding public agricultural land in South Africa.The reason for this is because “the nature, extent, trends and impact of land acquisition, land use and investment in the country’s land by foreign persons remains unknown as no comprehensive database exists to develop an understanding of such”, Nkwinti explains.

“The decade from 1997 to 2007 was characterised by significant shifts in ownership and land use including increasing acquisition of agricultural properties by foreign nationals in certain regions,” said Nkwinti. There is also an “absence of reliable information regarding the extent of agricultural land holdings owned by South Africans in terms of race and gender as well as the use and size of the land in question”.

If you own land…

As such, once the act commences every owner who owns a private agricultural land holding “must lodge a duly completed notification of ownership in the prescribed format with the commission within 12 months from the date of the commencement of this act”.

In this notification, they will be required to detail “the race, gender and nationality of the owner; the size and use of the agricultural land holdings; any real right registered against and licence allocated to the agricultural land holdings; and any other information as may be prescribed”.

Regarding the redistribution of agricultural land, black people must be offered the right of first refusal. “If no black person … acquires the redistribution agricultural land within the prescribed period, such land shall be acquired by the minister within the prescribed period.

“If the owner of the redistribution agricultural land and the minister are unable to reach an agreement on the purchase price, the minister may, subject to legislation regulating expropriation, expropriate the redistribution agricultural land in question,” said Nkwinti.

Land cap

Regarding a cap on how much land can be owned, Nkwinti said the minister will “determine the categories of ceilings for agricultural land holdings in each district” after the act is in place.

In 2015, he said foreigners with land holdings above the proposed cap of 12 000 hectares will – once the land holdings bill is signed into law – need to sell any excess agricultural holdings.

President Jacob Zuma

During his 2015 State of the Nation Address, President Jacob Zuma shocked the nation by announcing that foreigners in future would “not be able to own land” and would be forced to lease properties. He did not spell out what would happen to existing foreign-owned land, but said local farmers’ land would also be restricted to 12 000 hectares.

Reversing the legacy of colonialism and apartheid

The aim of the Regulation of Agricultural Land Holdings Bill is to reverse the legacy of colonialism and apartheid and to ensure a “just and equitable” distribution of agricultural land to Africans, the minister explained.

“The complexity of multiple tenure regimes as a result of a history of settler and imperial colonialism, dispossession and social engineering was acknowledged in the 1997 White Paper on Land Reform which proposed a further Green Paper on Tenure Reform.

“The current land tenure system can be traced back to the wars of colonial dispossession, which was entrenched through the heretic system of apartheid; and, legitimised through laws such as the Natives Land Act of 1913; the Native Administration Act of 1927; the Native Trust and Land Act of 1936; the Group Areas Act of 1950; the Promotion of Bantu Self-Government Act of 1959; the Bantu Authority Act of 1951; and, the Bantu Homelands Citizenship Act of 1970.” – Fin24


(Visited 200 times, 6 visits today)