Cathy Buckle: 409 farmers in Zimbabwe; it's all as clear as mud

Key topics:Zimbabwe land reform confusion and unclear policy signalsFarmers still waiting 26 years for compensation and restitutionOngoing dispute over seized land, property rights and trust.Sign up for your early morning brew of the BizNews Insider to keep you up to speed with the content that matters. The newsletter will land in your inbox every morning on weekdays. Register here.Support South Africa's bastion of independent journalism, offering balanced insights on investments, business, and the political economy, by joining BizNews Premium. Register here.If you prefer WhatsApp for updates, sign up to the BizNews channel here..By Cathy Buckle.Dear Family and Friends,On a cool May morning with pink clouds in the dawn sky, I looked up at the waning crescent of the Moon and thought about this Letter From Zimbabwe that I’ve been writing and sending to people around the world every fortnight for 26 years. It started with men at my farm gate throwing bricks and rocks as they began what became an eight-month road to hell as they seized the farm and everything on it and devastated the lives of everyone who lived and worked there. It was not an inherited farm, it had been legally bought and paid for 10 years after Independence with government approval but that made no difference to the men at the gate or the Zimbabwe Government. 26 years later the headlines this week are: ‘WE ARE NOT GIVING LAND BACK TO WHITE FARMERS.’ Those were the words of the Minister of Agriculture, Anxious Masuka who was apparently clarifying widespread reports of a land reform reversal. What followed was as clear as mud..Read more:.Cathy Buckle from Zim: For those who dare to differ.67 farms that were protected by BIPPA’s (Bilateral Investment Promotion and Protection Agreements) including from Denmark, Germany, the Netherlands and Switzerland would have their farms returned to them.840 indigenous farms that were wrongly gazetted at the height of the land reform programme would be returned to their black Zimbabwean owners.409 white Zimbabwean farmers who the Minister said have been ‘peacefully co-existing with local land reform beneficiaries’ would be allowed to purchase the farms they are now occupying, with a ‘set-off mechanism.’ A ‘set-off mechanism,’ is explained like this: if the government owes a farmer whose land they seized $500,000 in infrastructure compensation, and the purchase price of the land now is $500,000, the debts are cancelled out to facilitate ownership. “The land itself is being sold, not returned for free,” the Minister said.I can’t tell you how many times I’ve read this bizarre story which surely requires a comprehensive and clear policy paper for the future of agriculture and food security in Zimbabwe, not to mention property rights, Title Deeds that are worth the paper they are written on and good race relations. So far it’s all as clear as mud and aside from the 409 white farmers, the rest of us, around 4,000 ‘dispossessed’ farmers, continue to wait for our compensation. It’s been 26 years now. It begs this question though: if I go back and ‘occupy’ my own farm and ‘peacefully co-exist’ with the people who know they are living on contested land, will I be allowed to buy my own farm back again, the farm I’ve already paid for and whose Title Deeds I have? Why would I do that?All of this is morally incomprehensible whichever way you interpret it.I end this Letter with an extract from a Letter From Zimbabwe that I wrote 26 years ago in May 2000: The letter was called ‘Sacrificial Lambs’ and explained how 67 Marondera farmers were called to an emergency meeting held in the Ruzawi Club. I was there and we were told that in order to prevent 2000 farms from being sized by the government we had to decide who was prepared to sell their farms, who had had enough of land invasions and who was ready to give up. 26 years ago I described what happened: “It was all about who's prepared to be a sacrificial lamb. It's all a farce really because although 35% of farmers in one small area of Marondera said they would give up their farms, it's got to be done with compensation. Compensation, we were told, is not an issue that's been discussed yet because there isn't any money. What the government have suggested is that farmers would be given an I.O.U. and then, funds permitting, they would pay us out over a five or ten year period. These comments were met with the scorn and disgust that they deserve. What hope would any of us have of ever being paid and how the hell would we survive in the interim.” .Read more:.Zimbabwe's untouchables: A signature, a bribe, a blind eye - Cathy Buckle.That was 26 years ago. We are still waiting. Nothing has changed. Trust remains elusive. There is no charge for this Letter From Zimbabwe but if you would like to support my writing and donate please visit my website.My books “African Tears,” “Beyond Tears,” and “Can You Hear the Drums” tell the story of the invasion of my farm and others and the events that unfolded throughout Zimbabwe in the early years of farm seizures. These books are available from https://www.lulu.com/spotlight/cathybuckle2018Until next time, thanks for reading this Letter From Zimbabwe now in its 26th year, and my books about life in Zimbabwe, a country in waiting..Ndini shamwari yenyu (I am your friend)Love Cathy 14th May 2026. Copyright © Cathy Buckle https://cathybuckle.co.zw/ Please visit my website to see all my Books, Photobooks and Calendars https://cathybuckle.co.zw/

Cathy Buckle: 409 farmers in Zimbabwe; it's all as clear as mud

Related Stories

Inside solidarity's R3.2bn private varsity mega-project - Cape is next

Cathy Buckle: 'Go back to where you came from' Zim settlers are being told

Gas delays force SA to keep coal power stations running after their sell-by date

Miningweb: Australia’s mining sector faces a backlash over indigenous rights claims