Premium – Time to relook Naspers/Tencent ratios as concerns over the HK group resurface

Over the past five months, Naspers shares have done something very unusual. The stock, which, together with stablemate Prosus, has the heaviest weighting on JSE indices, is significantly outperforming its underlying asset Tencent..Our table above tracks the Naspers (blue) and Tencent (orange) share price changes over the past year. For many years Tencent has made the running. Since March 2023, however, Naspers shares have outperformed those of the Hong Kong internet giant by over 20%..___STEADY_PAYWALL___.Reflecting on this is relevant for at least two reasons. One is that despite being punching bags for many professional investors, the Naspers/Prosus management is bringing home the bacon. Its team's strategy to sell Tencent stock and use the cash to buy back Naspers shares has worked a treat. So far so good..Conversely, as you'll read in the well-researched piece below, the Tencent share price appears increasingly vulnerable. With Naspers having outperformed by so much, its shares are likely to be even more at risk should the predicted reverse hit the Hong Kong company's stock..Naspers is a popular holding in the Fantasy Fund Manager game – and in a personal capacity for many of the BizNews tribe. Shareholders have had a good run, particularly since October last year. Might be worth cashing in some of those gains. For the time being at least. .– Alec Hogg.Implications for JSE's highest weighted stock as Tencent's party starts to fade.By Jeanny Yu and Jane Zhang for Bloomberg.China's largest tech companies Alibaba Group Holding Ltd. and Tencent Holdings Ltd. have gained $66 billion in market value since May's end, propelled by expectations of a gradual return to pre-crackdown growth and a litany of official promises to unshackle the private sector. Yet some investors warn the celebration may be premature..For the first time since 2021, China's technology leaders head into an earnings season with what appears to be the wind at their backs. They're set to report their strongest growth rates in over a year. .Driven by a need to rejuvenate the world's No. 2 economy, Xi Jinping has in recent months led Party cadres and state media in proclaiming Beijing's support for a trillion-dollar sector wracked by two years of unpredictable diktats. And in July, Beijing signaled it's ready to unfetter the sector when it wrapped up a probe into Jack Ma-backed Ant Group Co..Still, investors betting on an inflection point risk getting ahead of themselves. .Chinese policymakers have stopped short of providing direct, major fiscal or policy support for businesses, and consumer spending remains muted thanks to a subdued outlook for wages and record-high youth unemployment. Profit margins remain thin amid rising competition from upstarts that mostly escaped the brunt of the crackdown such as ByteDance Ltd. and PDD Holdings Inc. .While a gauge of Chinese tech stocks has gained 20% since the end of May, it's down nearly 4% this month as nervous investors take some money off the table ahead of Alibaba's report. ."The bottom line is if China's economy is weak, it will be harder for these Internet companies to outgrow the economy now than before. And of course with all the new regulations and restrictions on these businesses, they are no longer free to seek growth," said Vey-Sern Ling, a managing director at Union Bancaire Privee.."The kind of growth that we saw in the past for China is unlikely to return," he adds..The quarterly prints will offer the first clue on whether the much-anticipated tech revival has truly begun. Yet even if Beijing hews to its promises, it's going to be a long slog to even approach the pre-2021 years of deal-making, experimentation and free-form expansion..Alibaba and Tencent, after shedding more than $350 billion of value since 2020, cut more than 20,000 jobs between them last year to survive regulatory and economic turmoil. They face a two-pronged assault: rivals like Baidu and Meituan are vying for dominance of the Internet thanks to the emergence of generative AI. Baidu has so far stolen much of their limelight in the post-ChatGPT race, debuting Ernie in March before launching into several iterations..Abroad, ByteDance and PDD's Temu continue to make strides, building on expansions that began when Alibaba and Tencent were forced to show restraint. During the crackdown, companies including ByteDance's TikTok, miHoYo, and Temu revved up overseas forays for growth. Despite rising geopolitical tensions, this generation of upstarts offer a template for older peers seeking to regain pre-crackdown heights.."At this very moment, the priority and the focus is on economic growth," Weijian Shan, executive chairman and co-founder of Hong Kong-based asset manager PAG, told Bloomberg Television last week. "The sentiment is rather weak and the confidence remains rather subdued. It takes couple years of policy stability for full confidence to return.".Alibaba and Tencent are also grappling with lingering uncertainty. Last week, investors got a brief reminder of the crackdown years when regulators — with little warning — published a set of rules limiting the amount of time minors can spend on their smartphones..In March, Alibaba announced a breakup into six mostly independent pieces, a historic split regarded as allowing its individual businesses to pursue new initiatives, while fulfilling Beijing's goal of cutting its most powerful private enterprises down to size. .With the split, the e-commerce leader is intent on creating a family of leaders in businesses from cloud computing and logistics to international commerce that couls seek funding and listing separately, appeasing shareholders hungry for value. Overseeing the momentous transition are two of Jack Ma's Alibaba co-founders, Eddie Wu and Joseph Tsai, who will replace eight-year veteran Daniel Zhang at the helm in September. It's unclear if either will helm the usual post-earnings briefing on Thursday.."Alibaba's business is highly leveraged to the economy because it's consumption based," Ling said. "In the past, Alibaba was able to outgrow the economy because e-commerce penetration was still low. Looking ahead, it may be harder to do so given high penetration of e-commerce, as well as competition from other platforms.".For Tencent, regulators appear tolerant of a resumption in video gaming, after years of warnings about addiction. But that in turn empowered rivals big and small..The world's largest games publisher has struggled to find its next big hit after mobile mainstays Honor of Kings and PUBG Mobile. Executives have declared Valorant its most important game of the year and set aside more than $100 million to spend on its content over the next three years. .But it needs to fight off a slew of big summer releases in China's $40 billion games arena, which contracted for the first time last year. These include games developed by closest rival NetEase Inc., anime specialist miHoYo and even ByteDance..On Monday, Goldman Sachs trimmed its estimates on Tencent's revenue by 0.5% to 0.8%, reflecting sliding ad sales. The broker also cut its target price for the stock by 3.3%. Tencent rose as much as 1% on Wednesday after two days of losses while Alibaba climbed 1.4%. ."Investors will eventually react to underlying earnings growth," said Jian Shi Cortesi, a fund manager at Gam Investment Management. "But I don't know when it will happen.".Read also:.Naspers set to outperform stablemate Prosus after cross-shareholding eliminatedNaspers delivers against strategic objectives and is on track to achieve profitability targetHow world sees SA: Rule of Law tested by Zuma's 'special remission' pardon

Premium – Time to relook Naspers/Tencent ratios as concerns over the HK group resurface

Related Stories

Deepfakes, boiler rooms, and bully tactics – The truth about FXSI: the scam targeting the BizNews tribe

Boardroom Talk: Berkshire after Buffett, the $373bn cash pile, and refusing to chase AI hype

Boardroom Talk: BN Portfolio Mag7 shine brightly in Q1

Boardroom Talk: Tesla’s big AI leap, Sasol’s oil surge and Teledyne’s quiet dominance