The world is changing fast and to keep up you need local knowledge with global context.
The hair protests, sparked by policy at Pretoria Girls’ High School, trumped Pravin Gordhan and SOE stories, according to data from media monitoring group Roi Africa. And it’s a theme that many feared could head the way the #FeeMustFall protests went. The debate still rages on what is an acceptable hairstyle, but it’s also widened into a race and language controversy. The submission by Kyle Findlay doesn’t dig into these issues but rather looks at how social media reacted to the events. The research is fascinating and well worth a read, as he’s developed some useful graphics around it all. The true power of the medium will be seen in what changes come about. The article was first published on his blog.
By Kyle Findlay*
I started collecting tweets that mentioned the controversy around Pretoria Girls High school’s hair policy (based on terms like “#StopRacismAtPretoriaGirlsHigh”, “hair AND racism”, etc.) a few days ago. I was a bit behind the curve, only picking up on it on the second day of action but still managed to collect 36,460 tweets from 30,175 different Twitter users. Let’s take a look at who the main communities were discussing this topic and what they had to say.
First, to set the scene, here’s what the overall tweet volumes that I collected looked like. The largest volume of tweets (aside potentially from the first day which I missed) was generated when the Sans Souci students entered the fray:
Here I’ve tagged the tweets mentioning each school and their related terms. You can see that Sans Souci really entered the picture on the 1st September, pushing overall conversation volumes up, although Pretoria Girls High still dominated in terms of overall mentions:
I then mapped the interaction network of users talking to and retweeting each other around this topic, and identified the sub-communities within it. It’s interesting to see how the international community picked up on the event. International users generated a significant proportion of all the tweets. The events particularly resonated with followers of international sites/accounts, @Blavity and @ajplus, but you can also see that many other international users’ posts about the incidents resonated with their own followers (recognizable by the little ‘firework explosions’ of retweets around key influencer accounts in the top half of the graph):
The other half of the conversation was made up by the South African Twittersphere, with the main local communities including Woke Twitter (think Rhodes Must Fall and various other fallists), Mainstream Twitter (including politicians and news agencies) and what I’ve called “Gauteng Twitter” (a mixture of races and political allegiances, making this community difficult to categorise but which seems centred around Pretoria and Jo’burg). I’ve highlighted these communities in the below graph. It’s important to note that, while these were the largest local communities, they only represented between 5-7% of users each and there were many other communities as well. In fact, the community distribution in this dataset is quite fractured, implying that there were many different groups discussing the topic. I’ve just highlighted a few of the largest.
Finally, here are some of the most retweeted tweets from each of the communities that I’ve highlighted.
These were some of the tweets that really resonated with the various international influencers and their communities:
— Blavity News (@Blavity) September 1, 2016
— philip lewis (@Phil_Lewis_) August 29, 2016
— Calestous Juma (@calestous) September 2, 2016
Pretoria high students take stand over school wanting them to relax/straighten their hair because it looks 'untidy' pic.twitter.com/SZY0SxZmrW
— Samira Sawlani (@samirasawlani) August 28, 2016
— AJ+ (@ajplus) August 30, 2016
Here are the top tweets in the Woke Twitter community. It’s interesting to see Independent Media’s Cape Times finding a place within this community since media houses seldom show up strongly within this highly decentralised community, except for The Daily Vox (whose in there too) and maybe Ground Up, but they often tend to cut across communities:
— Jameel (@indie_impimpi) September 2, 2016
— GroundUp (@GroundUp_News) September 1, 2016
— Cape Times (@CapeTimesSA) September 1, 2016
— Cape Times (@CapeTimesSA) September 1, 2016
The top tweets in the Mainstream Twitter community came from a mixture of influencers and politicians (including the EFF surprisingly):
— Ulrich Janse van Vuuren (@UlrichJvV) August 30, 2016
— Splinter (@splinter_news) August 30, 2016
Dear girls of #PretoriaGirlsHigh,
Please don't ever allow the prejudiced system of "society" to turn you into someone you're not!
— Ulrich Janse van Vuuren (@UlrichJvV) August 29, 2016
ANC should not patronize #PretoriaGirlsHigh by joining picket lines.Rather they should explain how come after 22yrs in power thy did nothing
— Mbuyiseni Ndlozi (@MbuyiseniNdlozi) August 29, 2016
Finally, the Gauteng Community was the most likely to offer a different, more flippant, interpretation of the events although this was quite a diverse community in terms of language and race so its difficult to really capture the full picture with just these top tweets:
— #UpdateAtNoon 104-107fm 📻 (@UpdateAtNoon) August 31, 2016
not to hate on pretoria girls high but this afro thingy has gone a bit far now pic.twitter.com/5lRVjHfdJC
— Chris Chameleon (@chrischameleon) August 31, 2016
— Palesa Morudu (@palesamorudu) August 30, 2016
So what are the conclusions to draw from this? Well, for one thing, most folks, black and white, seemed to recognise and support the girls’ protests. Also, I was surprised at the degree to which the incidents tapped into the international community, which shows us that the rest of the world has its eyes on South Africa and our race relations. We saw a similar thing during #FeesMustFall protests last year where the single most popular tweet was this one that tapped into the international community in a massive way:
— moroccan doll 💖🕯 (@dounia) October 23, 2015
- Kyle Findlay is an itinerant scholar with a deep love for South Africa. In his day job, he heads up a data science team for a large, international market research company.
Cyril Ramaphosa: The Audio Biography
Listen to the story of Cyril Ramaphosa's rise to presidential power, narrated by our very own Alec Hogg.