Should Mark Minnie not have been the one to have taken the test? The test proves that you absolutely believed everything that Minnie told you." But Cosmik Debris reminded Mike van Zyl that Mark Minnie is dead.
The polygraph really doesn't clarify anything. It does not prove that the contents of the book is true or correct; at best it possibly proves that Chris Steyn herself believes it to be true and correct. There's a huge difference between allegations actually being true and the person making them believing it to be true. I myself was a journalist during Steyn's time at The Star and have first-hand experience of her modus operandi as a journalist, which I would rather not discuss here. I would rather put my money on Jacques Pauw's story in Vrye Weekblad which pokes huge holes in Steyn's book. Alec, just as you believe your take on the polygraph story to be correct, you may still be proven wrong. And I am no apologist for the characters in Steyn's book – in fact I intensely disliked Malan and Wiley, whom I both met frequently in the course of my work, and I also intensely dislike any true child molester. But Steyn spared no thought for the immense harm she caused innocent people affected as collateral damage with her book of which her 'facts' were not proven beyond doubt and the allegations of her sources were not cross-checked and corroborated. It seems her only concern was sensationalism and good book sales. Alec, it's sad to see someone of your journalistic calibre falling for a polygraph test that seems to be little more than just another con in a battle to shape public perceptions."