Worldview: Starlink saga - Musk’s BEE clash exposes race, investment, and digital sovereignty divide

Key topics:Musk challenges BEE laws blocking Starlink’s SA entryGovernment proposes investment alternative to Black ownership rulesDebate sparks tensions over race, regulation, and sovereignty.Sign up for your early morning brew of the BizNews Insider to keep you up to speed with the content that matters. The newsletter will land in your inbox at 5:30am weekdays. Register here.Support South Africa's bastion of independent journalism, offering balanced insights on investments, business, and the political economy, by joining BizNews Premium. Register here.If you prefer WhatsApp for updates, sign up to the BizNews channel here..By Kerry Lanaghan.Listen to this story instead:.South Africa is on the verge of reshaping its telecommunications policy as it grapples with whether to allow Starlink - Elon Musk’s satellite internet service - to operate within the country. The core issue centres around South Africa’s Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) laws, which require foreign companies to sell ownership stakes to Black South Africans or those previously disadvantaged under apartheid. Musk has publicly denounced these laws as discriminatory, claiming they block Starlink from entering his country of birth.In response, Solly Malatsi, South Africa’s communications minister and a member of the Democratic Alliance (DA), is proposing a workaround: allowing satellite companies to meet transformation requirements by investing in underserved communities rather than selling equity. The move, which still requires approval from the communications regulator after public consultation, has drawn sharp criticism from political opponents, particularly from the ruling African National Congress (ANC). Critics argue that relaxing ownership rules undermines decades-long efforts to address apartheid-era inequalities.Khusela Sangoni Diko, chair of the parliamentary committee on telecommunications, accused Malatsi of eroding “hard-won transformation goals” and pandering to Musk. She noted that other satellite providers are willing to comply with the existing regulations, suggesting there’s no need for special treatment. Malatsi insists the policy shift isn’t about Musk but about attracting broader investment. He pointed out that other sectors already use “equity equivalents” to meet BEE obligations and said such strategies have spurred growth in industries like automotive manufacturing.Starlink, which is licensed in 20 African countries, has argued that its high-speed, affordable satellite internet could help South Africa meet its development goals - especially in underserved rural areas. However, the controversy surrounding Musk’s public comments continues to cast a long shadow. South African officials are wary of granting Starlink too much influence, citing Musk’s X (formerly Twitter) posts promoting misinformation, including a conspiracy theory that white South Africans face genocide and criticism of the country’s land reform laws as racist.These tensions have been further inflamed by the return of US President Donald Trump, who has cut American aid to South Africa and offered refugee status to white South Africans. President Cyril Ramaphosa’s office confirmed that while he once discussed broader investment from Musk - including potential Tesla and SpaceX involvement - those talks are on hold due to Musk’s “untruthful posts” and the worsening diplomatic climate.As South Africa navigates this fraught intersection of race, regulation, and foreign investment, the Starlink debate encapsulates broader questions about transformation, economic pragmatism, and national sovereignty in the digital age.(This article is a précis of a piece originally published in The New York Times and can be read in full here.)Read also:RW Johnson: Why the ANC’s decline now looks inevitableTrump's "madman" diplomacy backfires as talks with Iran falterIRR seeks allies in MKP, EFF to stop elite-enriching BEE policies funnelling billions to super-rich

Worldview: Starlink saga - Musk’s BEE clash exposes race, investment, and digital sovereignty divide

Key topics:

Related Stories