Premium: US Media quietly admits its Gupta Leaks, dismissed as fake news, was real

The story at the bottom of the page is required reading for anyone retaining illusions that all media strives for free and fair reporting. At a critical point in the 2020 US Election, instead of acting as Democracy's bulwark in the Court of Public Opinion, news organisations chose a side. The wrong one. Not just in the US..When the New York Post published its expose' on incriminating documents found on Hunter Biden's abandoned computer, the US media establishment – led by The New York Times – wrote it off as fake news. Twitter even blocked the Post's account for two weeks. Now, 18 months later, all have quietly recanted..At BizNews, the story reminded us of SA's Gupta Leaks, where explosive information was extracted from an abandoned computer. BizNews satirist SLR devoted a column to the subject and we republished coverage by the WSJ. Elsewhere, the media's distaste of the incumbent, trumped its ethics..___STEADY_PAYWALL___.Two other things shocked me about reactions to our approach. First, despite Hunter's local connection (his wife is from Cape Town) SA media all swallowed Biden's "fake news" line. Second, as a direct result of this, some long-time BizNews supporters cancelled subscriptions and made sure I knew why. Slips are showing. Not just on this topic..More for you to read today:.China's Big Tech Firms Are Axing Thousands of Workers. Tencent, Alibaba and Didi are among companies in the process of slashing jobs this year as they face economic and regulatory headwindsElon Musk's Business Ties to China Create Unease in Washington. Tesla, SpaceX are at the centre of discussions; some lawmakers fear Beijing could access secrets as 'Congress doesn't have good eyes on this'Russia, Failing to Achieve Early Victory in Ukraine, Is Seen Shifting to 'Plan B', a Siege. Tactical shift seeks to pressure Ukraine into accepting neutrality and Russian territorial claims, U.S. officials say. (see video above)US Stocks End Lower Monday After Powell Interest-Rate Comments. Oil prices advance, remain elevated above $110 a barrel.Hunter Biden's Laptop and America's Crisis of Accountability.The New York Times now admits the story was real. News and social-media companies will pay no price for suppressing vital information in 2020..By Gerard Baker of The Wall Street Journal.In close elections, a fraction of the total vote distributed in the right places can swing an outcome, and we can never be sure what effect late news stories can have..If it hadn't been for a suspiciously well-timed report of a decades-old driving-under-the-influence arrest in the final days of the 2000 presidential campaign, George W. Bush might not have needed 35 days and the judgment of the Supreme Court to deliver him the White House..Harold Wilson, the British Labour prime minister in 1970, is said to have claimed for years afterward that England's shock defeat by West Germany in the soccer World Cup quarterfinal that year so depressed the national mood—and turnout—that it produced his surprise ejection from 10 Downing Street in the general election days later..We'll never know what effect the "October Surprise" of 2020, the New York Post's reporting of the discovery of a laptop belonging to Hunter Biden containing all sorts of embarrassing emails, might have had on the election that year if it had received wider circulation. Perhaps in a campaign dominated by Covid and characterized by chaos, it would have been another snowflake in the blizzard of news voters were being hit with..But the allegations in the reporting—that the son of the man favored to become the next president had been selling his high-level family political connections to foreigners, including suggestions of a possible cut for his father—were worth pursuing. But enough influential people in and out of government—in the foreign-policy-intelligence complex, in the media, and in the big tech firms—were so alarmed that it would affect the outcome that they pulled off one of the greatest disappearing tricks since Harry Houdini made that elephant vanish from a New York stage..It took its time, but last week the New York Times slipped the acknowledgment of the story's accuracy deep in a report about Hunter Biden's mounting legal problems. The Times, along with most other mass-circulation news organizations, had essentially ignored the story in the days when it might have made a difference, but it now says it has "authenticated" the laptop's contents..The concession from the paper, which serves as a sort of unofficial licensing authority for reporting by most of the rest of the media, prompted a predictable rush to self-vindication by those who had also trashed the story at the time. The Washington Post insisted its original decision not to touch it was justified because of uncertainty about its provenance..Normally, when there is doubt about the provenance of an explosive story, news organizations consider it their job to ascertain the truth. Normally, it takes them less than 17 months to do so. But normally they don't have the cover provided by technology companies that prevented people from reading the original story..The media and tech companies that colluded in concealing this potentially critical information didn't need any excuse to do so. But it surely helped that they were given validation for their actions by an august-sounding committee of concerned letter-writers who moved quickly to discredit the story..In that famous letter, more than 50 former national-security and intelligence officials polished their gleaming credentials and alleged that the New York Post was guilty of peddling a story that had "all the classic earmarks of a Russian information operation.".The principal rationale for this, the letter laid out, was that the story might be helpful to Donald Trump. Russia wanted Mr. Trump to win. The story helped Mr. Trump. Ergo, it was the work of Russia..That's quite a syllogism. Using that same logic, you might conclude that Russia was also responsible for any unexpectedly good economic data that helped the incumbent, or that Vladimir Putin was behind the crime wave that had gripped Democrat-run cities..Now we can guess why so much U.S. intelligence has been so faulty all these years. Either these 50 or so grandmasters of international espionage are completely unable to distinguish Russian disinformation from real information, or they prostituted their credentials in a naked act of political hackery. I don't have their experience or deductive skills, but I'm ready to go with the latter..The deeper shame here is the lack of accountability across American institutions. No one who colluded in this conspiracy against truth has even been inconvenienced by it..Contacted by the Post last week, not one of the letter's signatories expressed regret or contrition. The reporters and editors at news organizations and the employees and executives of tech companies who participated in the suppression continue to be lionized for their work..This is what is so corrosive of trust and, in the end, of the system itself. The one way in which real accountability is supposed to work in a democracy is at the ballot box. But how can that even work when the people we want to hold accountable decide what information the voters are allowed to see?.NB FOR YOUR WALL STREET JOURNAL ACCESS….As a Premium subscriber you are entitled to full membership of wsj.com (normal price $29 a month). Be sure to action your access through the Premium link on the BizNews website. Because of The Wall Street Journal's credential requirements, be sure to create a password which has at least 8 characters and includes at least one letter and one number – NB it MAY NOT contain any special characters (ie #, !, @ etc). To maintain access to WSJ.com, you MUST enter our partner's website via BizNews Premium at least once a month. A final PS, if you had previously signed up for WSJ you'll need to clear the cookies from your device. Our help desk can assist – support@biznews.com..If you'd like to help sustain our independent voice, why not share the love by making a gift that keeps giving? Click here to access the BizNews Premium subscription signup form, and be sure tick the relevant box. At R100 a month and inclusive of full membership of The Wall Street Journal, it's a mind-expanding gift at an incredibly modest price.

Premium: US Media quietly admits its Gupta Leaks, dismissed as fake news, was real

Related Stories

Meet Tshepo Mahloele – Big Capitec shareholder, ABSIP’s “CEO of the Decade” now accused by Holomisa as kingpin of corrupt network

PREMIUM: Making of a great editor – the George Palmer playbook

Premium – BizNews global portfolio: ASML joins – so does Adobe as Bull takes hold again

Alec Hogg: Helen Zille predicts SA choice will be DA or EFF