Ramaphosa's R700m National Dialogue faces backlash over elitism, exclusion

Key topics:National Dialogue to cost estimated R700 million.Government promises inclusive, nationwide public engagements.Neil de Beer criticises elite panel and political motives..Sign up for your early morning brew of the BizNews Insider to keep you up to speed with the content that matters. The newsletter will land in your inbox at 5:30am weekdays. Register here.Support South Africa’s bastion of independent journalism, offering balanced insights on investments, business, and the political economy, by joining BizNews Premium. Register here.If you prefer WhatsApp for updates, sign up to the BizNews channel here.The auditorium doors will open for BNIC#2 on 10 September 2025 in Hermanus. For more information and tickets, click here..By Kerry Lanaghan.Listen to this story instead:.The ambitious National Dialogue initiative, spearheaded by President Cyril Ramaphosa, is expected to cost the State more than R700 million, according to estimates from the dialogue’s preparatory committee.Announced at a media briefing in Johannesburg on Friday, 13 June 2025, the committee outlined a comprehensive plan that includes a national convention scheduled for 15 August 2025, as well as a series of public and community engagements across all nine provinces.EWN has made a report stating that the initiative is being positioned as a nationwide effort to confront South Africa’s social, economic, and political challenges through inclusive dialogue. The preparatory task team, led by figures such as Mduduzi Mbada, Oyama Mabandla, and Nkosinathi Biko, said the dialogue would involve all sectors of society - from government and labour to civil society and grassroots communities.The projected R700 million cost is primarily earmarked for extensive outreach efforts. According to Mbada, these costs are necessary to ensure every community is reached and heard: “Democracy is not cheap. Building a nation is very costly. Just to pull the provinces and municipalities is an estimation of probably more than R700 million.”While the figure may raise eyebrows in the current economic climate, the committee insists the funds will deliver significant long-term value by laying the groundwork for a renewed national consensus.Chairperson of the committee, Nkosinathi Biko, echoed the president’s recent remarks, framing the dialogue as a chance to build a "new social compact."“As President Ramaphosa said in his address on Tuesday, it is an opportunity to forge a new social compact for the development of our country - a compact that will unite all South Africans with clear responsibilities for different stakeholders: government, business, labour, civil society, men and women,” Biko said.However, in a wide-ranging interview with BizNews’ Chris Steyn, United Independent Movement president Neil de Beer delivered a scathing critique of the initiative, questioning both its sincerity and structure. “Chris, how do you stuff up a National Dialogue?” he asked rhetorically, suggesting that rather than being a genuine platform for reconciliation, the dialogue appears to be a stage-managed effort by the ANC ahead of the 2026 elections.De Beer said he had once hoped for a meaningful, grassroots-driven process - a “massive annual roadshow” taken to every province, where “every single differentiation of a nation” could be heard. Instead, he argues, the current structure excludes ordinary South Africans in favour of elite appointees, including what he described as a puzzling panel of “academics, artists, and political has-beens,” lacking representation from the working class and notably omitting voices from the Afrikaner community.He also blasted the R700 million price tag: “When I heard the cost, all I could think was Zondo, Zondo, Zondo,” he said, referencing past expensive commissions that produced volumes of documents but little tangible reform. “Ons is gatvol of your documents and your procedures, commissions…and all of your meetings. This country needs leadership. It doesn’t need conferences about leadership,” he concluded.The national convention in August will bring together key stakeholders to set the tone and agenda for the community engagements. These engagements, which will unfold in towns, villages, and urban centres throughout South Africa, are expected to culminate in an action plan aimed at addressing the country’s most pressing issues.The dialogue comes at a critical time, as South Africa grapples with deep socio-economic divisions, high unemployment, service delivery failures, and waning public trust in institutions.The committee is urging all citizens to actively participate in the upcoming engagements. “This isn’t just about talking; it’s about shaping the future together,” preparatory task team member Nkosinathi Biko said.The final draft budget will be submitted to the government in the coming weeks, after which further planning sessions and budget workshops will be held. But as figures like Neil de Beer warn, the dialogue’s success will ultimately rest on its inclusivity and credibility, and whether it can speak to the plumber, not just the professor.

Ramaphosa's R700m National Dialogue faces backlash over elitism, exclusion

Key topics:

Related Stories