Zuma v Pravin – owners of SA’s Big Four banks down R100bn in two weeks

By Alec Hogg

In a report published on Tuesday, independent financial analyst Mark Ingham suggested the day the Hawks started gunning for Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan, 23/8, was turning into a “mini 9/12” – the day Nenegate began.

The numbers show it’s not that “mini” anymore. In the last two weeks, share prices of SA’s Big Four banks are all down double digits in percentage terms. As a result, FirstRand, Standard, Barclays Africa and Nedbank are worth a staggering R100bn less than a fortnight back.

After Gordhan’s predecessor Nhlanhla Nene was fired on December 9th last year, the market value of these four companies dropped R127bn in two days. That, together with surging bond rates and a plunging Rand, was enough to force President Jacob Zuma to atone and reappoint the Finmin he’d demoted two years earlier.

In a developing country like SA, big banking stocks are excellent barometers of investor confidence. The current selloff might have taken longer than Nenegate, but it sends the same message. Capital is cowardly. It heads for the exit when feeling unsafe. This time it has been walking rather than running. But is leaving all the same. Is anybody listening?

Mkt cap 19 Aug (Rm) Mkt cap now (Rm) Loss (Rm)
FIRSTRAND 281 708 243 844 – 37 864
STANBANK 242 741 210 692 – 32 049
B-AFRICA 139 879 121 228 – 18 651
NEDBANK 111 999 100 786 – 11 213
TOTAL – 99 777
Visited 28 times, 1 visit(s) today