BNC London: Lorimer Q&A – How SA can unlock its vast oil and gas potential

In a dynamic Q&A between Alec Hogg and James Lorimer, the shadow minister of Mineral Resources, the discussion spans from Namibia’s significant oil finds to South Africa’s energy landscape. Lorimer highlights potential job creation and revenue influx from oil and gas, while acknowledging policy hurdles. With insights into fracking, renewable energy, and electoral prospects, the dialogue offers a comprehensive view of energy and politics.

Sign up for your early morning brew of the BizNews Insider to keep you up to speed with the content that matters. The newsletter will land in your inbox at 5:30am weekdays. Register here.


Watch here

Listen here


Summary of the Q&A session with James Lorimer at BNC London

In an engaging Q&A session between Alec Hogg and James Lorimer, Shadow Minister of Mineral Resources, various aspects of South Africa’s potential in the oil and gas industry were discussed. Lorimer provided insights into significant oil finds in Namibia, contrasting the ease of doing business there with the complexities in South Africa due to legislative hurdles and policy uncertainties. He highlighted the potential economic benefits, including job creation and revenue generation, emphasizing the urgency of exploiting these resources amidst budget cuts and economic challenges.

The conversation delved into the global energy landscape, addressing the role of fracking and the slow transition away from fossil fuels. Lorimer stressed the importance of responsible resource extraction, acknowledging past environmental concerns while advocating for proper regulation to mitigate risks. Additionally, he touched on the political dynamics affecting investment decisions, citing examples of international companies navigating South Africa’s regulatory environment.

Concerns about South Africa’s energy future and political landscape were also raised. Lorimer discussed the challenges of nuclear energy development, cautioning against government mismanagement, and emphasized the need for stable, investor-friendly policies to attract capital and spur economic growth. The discussion extended to South Africa’s upcoming elections, reflecting on the Democratic Alliance’s electoral prospects amidst media bias and political attacks.

Overall, the dialogue provided valuable insights into the complexities of South Africa’s energy sector, highlighting the need for strategic policy reforms to unlock the country’s potential and navigate global energy transitions effectively.

Edited transcript of the Q&A session with James Lorimer at BNC London 

Alec Hogg [00:00:07]: Your insights were captivating, presenting prospects akin to a real estate agent, starting with the less favorable options first. Can you shed light on South Africa’s potential on a global scale?

James Lorimer [00:00:50]: Namibia’s potential is indeed significant. When we look at the broader context, it’s crucial to recognize that Namibia stands out as one of the most promising regions.

Alec Hogg [00:02:52]: You mentioned fracking’s potential impact on South Africa’s economy. Was it underestimated?

James Lorimer [00:03:19]: Not at all. The transformative impact of fracking, particularly observed in the US, serves as a testament to its potential. The economic boost, job creation, and revenue generation associated with fracking are significant. We must acknowledge its potential to reshape South Africa’s economic landscape positively.

Alec Hogg [00:04:47]: Why deliver this positive message as opposition, especially with ANC silent?

James Lorimer [00:05:28]: It’s essential to highlight the potential benefits that could be realized through strategic legislative adjustments. As the opposition, it’s our duty to advocate for policies that foster economic growth and development. By drawing attention to these opportunities, we aim to spark constructive dialogue and action for the betterment of our country’s future.

Alec Hogg [00:08:55]: Namibia leads. Why? Can SA catch up?

James Lorimer [00:10:27]: Namibia’s progress can be attributed to its conducive regulatory environment and proactive approach to resource development. In contrast, South Africa’s legislative framework presents challenges that hinder progress. However, with strategic reforms and concerted efforts, South Africa can narrow the gap and capitalize on its abundant resources. It’s a matter of aligning policies with the potential for sustainable growth and development.

Alec Hogg [00:11:23]: What about Shell’s recent moves?

James Lorimer [00:11:23]: Shell’s strategic realignment is part of its global business strategy, reflecting broader trends in the energy sector. While there may be implications for South Africa, it’s essential to consider the larger context of Shell’s business decisions. It underscores the need for a competitive and attractive investment environment to retain and attract industry players, ensuring continued growth and prosperity in the sector.

Alec Hogg [00:12:57]: Are there signs of change?

James Lorimer [00:13:21]: Change is gradual, particularly within the ANC’s entrenched agenda. However, progress in the energy sector signals a potential shift towards more conducive policies. It’s a step in the right direction, albeit requiring sustained efforts to overcome institutional barriers and drive meaningful reform. According to the polls, the narrative France described aligns closely with what we’ve been hearing. However, this pattern is emblematic of South African elections. Over the years between elections, support for alternative parties builds as people witness the shortcomings of ANC governance. Yet, come election time, there’s a barrage of attacks on the DA from various quarters, often fueled by the media. The DA is painted as a white party, accused of racism, and scrutinized for its governance. Despite the evidence to the contrary, particularly evident in the Western Cape’s stark contrast, these narratives take a toll on support. However, we still anticipate surpassing our previous performance, albeit with a degree of disappointment. A significant factor contributing to this dynamic is the media environment.

Alec Hogg [00:14:56]: Could you elaborate on that?

James Lorimer [00:14:58]: Certainly. Much of the media landscape is populated by individuals with ties to the ANC, whether through past affiliations or voting history. While they may have shifted their political allegiances, their worldview is still influenced by their backgrounds. This predisposes them to defend the ANC or, more notably, to critique the DA for its commitment to principles like free enterprise, which some find disagreeable. Operating within such a challenging media landscape has undoubtedly impacted our messaging and perception. However, we’re increasingly cognizant of this reality and are striving to address it more effectively in the future.

Alec Hogg [00:15:45]: What do you envision as a successful outcome for the DA in this election?

James Lorimer [00:16:00]: A higher percentage of the national vote compared to the last election would undoubtedly be deemed a success. Additionally, we see a strong possibility of forging governing coalitions, particularly in crucial provinces like Gauteng and possibly even KwaZulu-Natal. The latter presents an intriguing scenario, considering the DA’s unexpectedly robust performance there. The emergence of credible black opposition parties, such as MK, is a noteworthy trend. It signals a shift in mindset, making it more acceptable for black voters to consider alternatives to the ANC. This psychological shift holds promise for future electoral dynamics.

Alec Hogg [00:17:51]: How mature would you say South Africa’s democracy is at present?

James Lorimer [00:18:10]: South Africa’s democracy is still significantly influenced by its past, a reality not uncommon in post-colonial nations. However, there are promising signs, particularly among younger voters, whose attitudes appear more flexible and open to change. While the legacy of apartheid and ANC rule still looms large, there’s a gradual evolution towards a more mature democracy, albeit with its challenges and setbacks along the way.

Alec Hogg [00:18:47]: Is there a risk that global attitudes towards gas production might shift unfavorably before meaningful production ramps up?

James Lorimer [00:19:21]: The risk of global disinvestment in gas seems minimal, considering its continued significance in the energy landscape. Despite environmental concerns, gas remains a vital transition fuel, especially as countries seek alternatives to coal. The recent commitment of even environmentally conscious governments, like Australia’s, to major gas projects underscores its enduring importance. Therefore, while challenges exist, the trajectory for gas production seems relatively stable.

Alec Hogg [00:19:34]: Could you delve into how government policies impact business access to natural resources and the subsequent limitations on potential?

James Lorimer [00:20:41]: Government policies indeed play a pivotal role in shaping business access to natural resources, often introducing complexities and impediments that hinder potential. For instance, requirements to allocate a percentage of projects to empowerment interests can strain the financial viability of investments. Moreover, partnerships with entities lacking financial capacity or understanding of the industry pose additional risks. These factors cumulatively deter investment and undermine the sector’s growth potential.

Alec Hogg [00:21:29]: The length and complexity of the ballot paper pose challenges for voters. How do you see this impacting the electoral landscape?

James Lorimer [00:23:39]: The proliferation of parties and complexity of the ballot paper undoubtedly complicates the electoral process, particularly for voters with limited literacy. While party symbols and pictures mitigate some confusion, the risk of miscasting votes persists. Moreover, the absence of clear definitions of community in resource allocation exacerbates tensions and fosters conflicts. Despite these challenges, the electoral system endures, albeit with room for improvement in simplification and voter education initiatives.

Alec Hogg [00:24:00]: Concerns have been raised regarding the accuracy of resource extraction claims, particularly in the case of LNG findings in the Northern Free State. What insights can you offer on this?

James Lorimer [00:25:26]: The accuracy of resource extraction claims, especially regarding LNG findings, remains a contentious issue. While some companies may prioritize helium extraction, the presence of natural gas adds a layer of complexity to operations. Challenges related to transportation, infrastructure, and community expectations further complicate the viability of such ventures. However, despite these hurdles, there remains optimism regarding the potential of these resources, albeit with cautionary notes on the unpredictability inherent in the industry.

Alec Hogg [00:26:35]: Do you anticipate challenges in maintaining required rates of return amid policy uncertainties and additional risks?

James Lorimer [00:31:02]: Indeed, navigating policy uncertainties and mitigating risks are paramount considerations for long-term capital investments, particularly in cyclical projects like resource extraction. The evolving regulatory landscape, coupled with localized challenges, necessitates a recalibration of investment strategies to maintain desired returns. While South Africa grapples with these issues, there’s a recognition of the need for resilience and adaptability to capitalize on the abundant opportunities despite the prevailing uncertainties.

Read also: