FT: With Bluesky, the social media echo chamber is back in vogue

The exodus from Elon Musk's X, formerly Twitter, has seen users, particularly progressives, migrate to alternative platforms like Bluesky and Threads. Disillusioned by Musk's controversial direction, including his "civil war is inevitable" comments, X's user base has significantly declined, with UK active users dropping by a third. Bluesky, known for its cosy echo chamber atmosphere, is becoming a favoured space for media professionals and academics, echoing the early days of Twitter. However, the shift highlights a deepening divide in social media, ironically driven by Musk's initial warnings about such splintering..Sign up for your early morning brew of the BizNews Insider to keep you up to speed with the content that matters. The newsletter will land in your inbox at 5:30am weekdays. Register here..By Jemima Kelly.The great migration from Elon Musk's X has seen users, especially progressives, retreat into one particular silo .___STEADY_PAYWALL___."There is currently great danger," a man wrote two years ago, "that social media will splinter into far right wing and far left wing echo chambers that generate more hate and divide our society.".It may surprise you to learn that the man in question was Elon Musk, who wrote these words when he bought the social media platform formerly known as Twitter back in October 2022, stressing the need for humanity to have a "common digital town square" that was "warm and welcoming to all", not a "free-for-all hellscape"..And yet . . . and yet. .Repelled by the direction that both the site now called X and its owner have taken, an exodus from the platform is under way. That exodus — oh go on then, Xodus — has been particularly apparent in Britain, having gathered steam since Musk started posting things like "civil war is inevitable" during the riots that broke out over the summer. Many have left the platform entirely, while others merely lurk. "I have an answer to this, but discussion only on Bluesky these days am afraid [sic]," I saw someone reply on X recently. .Read more: 🔒 Elon Musk's X goes dark in Brazil amid free speech clash.Either way, activity has fallen discernibly. Data from Similarweb shows active daily users in the UK have dropped from 8mn a year ago to only around 5.6mn now, with more than a third of that fall coming since the summer riots. The same thing is happening elsewhere, and not just in places where the platform has been banned, such as Brazil. Over the same 16-month period, X's active users in the US have fallen by about a fifth..As disillusioned X users become, yes, ex-X-users, they are finding their way on to alternative sites. With Mastodon having proved off-puttingly techy for many, that tends to either be Meta's Threads app, or Bluesky, the platform that Twitter founder Jack Dorsey helped to start. But while the former is winning in terms of absolute numbers — about 1.4mn daily active users of Threads in the UK, compared with just over 100,000 for Bluesky — it is the latter that has grown the most rapidly over the past six weeks, and that is cementing itself as the top choice for media types, policy wonks, academics and the broader chatterati..That there is a new place for such people to congregate is all well and good, but the problem is that the chatterati — very nice and non-conspiracy-theorising and non-overtly-racist though they may be — tend to coalesce around some quite similar viewpoints, which makes for a rather echoey chamber. I'm not sure I have ever felt more like I'm at a Stoke Newington drinks party than when I'm browsing Bluesky (including when tucking into Perelló olives and truffle-flavoured Torres crisps in actual N16)..An even more fundamental problem is that nobody on Bluesky seems to actually mind that they are in an echo chamber. When I told a friend, who happens to be an enthusiastic Bluesky user, what I was writing about this week, she replied "oh yes, but it is an echo chamber, that's what people like about it, it's lovely"..Many enthuse about how like "old Twitter" Bluesky is, which is telling in itself: in the old days of Twitter, progressives far outnumbered their conservative counterparts in terms of how much they posted about politics on the platform, but that share has fallen dramatically since Musk took it over. According to the British Election Study, in the run-up to both the 2015 and 2019 elections, about 30 per cent of the most progressive Britons posted about politics on the platform. This year, while the most conservative Britons remained no less likely to post than before, the share of progressives posting on X had halved to 15 per cent; presumably that has since fallen much further, given that this survey preceded the riots..In many ways this is all fair enough. Many of us use video-first platforms like Instagram and TikTok as procrastination-cum-entertainment; why shouldn't the text-based social media sites be a place for procrastination-cum-cosy-filter-bubbling? Why not have a place on the internet that you can go and have a nice, civilised chat with someone who shares your worldview without the risk of coming across a load of vile racist content?.It comes down, in the end, to whether or not you believe that the "digital town square" Musk talked about when he bought Twitter can really exist and, if it can, whether it is of any benefit to anyone..I have previously argued that a "digital town square" is a contradiction in terms — the internet is never going to enable the kind of engagement and understanding that comes from coming up against a real person in all their raw and imperfect humanity..But while it will always be much messier and more maddening than we might like, I believe such a place is preferable to a series of siloed echo chambers. The irony is that it is the man who warned of the "great danger" of a splintering-off who is most responsible for making that a reality..Read also:.🔒 Meta's Threads celebrates one year of competition with Elon Musk's X🔒 Elon Musk's xAI raises $6bn, escalating rivalry with OpenAIElon Musk's X loses half its value within a year.© 2024 The Financial Times Ltd.

FT: With Bluesky, the social media echo chamber is back in vogue

Related Stories

UK demographic crisis: Birth rates hit historic lows

Mass drone production has turned the war in Ukraine's favour

Mark Oppenheimer: Joburg Bar's undeniable race-based admissions

Epstein files trigger sweeping police probe into (former) Prince Andrew