Tale of the tape: Tom Moyane’s history of bringing SARS into disrepute – Pressly

JOHANNESBURG — Cape Messenger editor Donwald Pressly has put together a comprehensive summary of now-suspended Commissioner of SARS Tom Moyane’s debacles at the tax collector. Reading this, it becomes incredibly clear that President Cyril Ramaphosa had no option but to suspend him. – Gareth van Zyl

By Donwald Pressly*

It was just a matter of time. It was clear that Tom Moyane, the South African Revenue Service commissioner, was in the firing line. President Cyril Ramaphosa did not act immediately. He has given those apparently implicated in the Gupta infection of the state just enough time to start feeling secure. Then he acted. Ramaphosa asked Moyane to resign, but he refused. Now he has been suspended. A disciplinary process will now ensue.

Donwald Pressly

The decision to suspend Moyane “follows a meeting in which President Ramaphosa informed Mr Moyane that he had lost confidence in his ability to lead SARS and offered him an opportunity to resign with immediate effect, which Mr Moyane declined”. The presidency issued a statement late on Monday night.

The President indicated that as SARS commissioner, Moyane “holds a high position of trust in the management of the country’s public finances. It was, therefore, necessary to act urgently and immediately to protect the institution and place it on a path to stability and recovery”.

Ramaphosa was concerned about the management of VAT refunds which had brought the SARS “into serious disrepute and potentially jeopardised the integrity of the SARS as collector of revenue and adversely affected tax morality among taxpayers”. Here is the Gupta link the Moyane tale – although Ramaphosa did not go into the details of this matter.

There is a mountain of evidence, however, that Moyane instructed SARS to make VAT refunds to the account of Terbium Financial Services – a third party and not the registered VAT vendor which was the Gupta company, Oakbay. This is in contravention of provisions of the VAT Act. The amount paid to the Guptas amounted to R70 million. Only yesterday – Monday 19 March – Moyane blamed the messenger, the media, for misrepresenting the good work of SARS (see full statement below).

In the SARS statement Moyane accused the media of focusing “all its venom” on himself by accusing him of illegally authorising a VAT payment amounting to R70 million “to a taxpayer” – he did not acknowledge the Gupta family – “despite ample proof that he had no role in the payment and had acted within the law”.

Now-suspended SARS Commissioner Tom Moyane

The president’s other concern about Moyane’s management was the handling of the matter of the chief officer for business and individual tax Jonas Makwakwa. “His treatment of the report given to him (about Makwakwa) by the Financial Intelligence Centre, and his failure to immediately report this to the Minister of Finance,” had raised the president’s concern, said Khusela Diko, spokesperson to the president. The Minister of Finance that Ramaphosa was referring to was Pravin Gordhan at the time of the FIC report – provided to SARS in mid-2016.

Makwakwa resigned last Wednesday, 14 March. Makwakwa apparently misled SARS over the appointment of the National Integrated Credit Solutions (NICS) as one of eight debt collectors to recover billions of rand in debt owed to the taxman. NICs was appointed despite being linked to payments of money to Makwakwa’s personal account. It was this matter which was raised by the FIC. The FIC traced the payments by the Department of Water and Sanitation to NICS.

The allegation is that some R1.2 million was paid to Makwakwa between 2010 and 2016 although Moyane refers to a lower figure of “over R400 000” (See below). TimesLive reported last week that Makwakwa declared no relationship with NICS and had not declared that he had been a director in Biz Fire Worx, a company where the money from the water department ended up before allegedly being paid into his personal account. Makwakwa resigned ahead of SARS suspending him.

At the first and last main budget briefing – in February this year – delivered by then Finance Minister Malusi Gigaba, the minister indicated that action would be taken against Makwakwa. He did not, however, indicate that there was any action about to be taken against Moyane – who was sitting alongside Gigaba at a media briefing at parliament, which was part of the routine lock-up of journalists ahead of the tabling of the main Budget. Significantly Moyane never attended when Gordhan was Finance Minister.

Moyane stood by his man, Makwakwa to the end

In the face of evidence that Makwakwa was deeply embroiled in wrongdoing, Moyane stood by Makwakwa even on the day of announcing the latter’s resignation. “I wish to announce that Mr Jonas Mashudi Makwakwa has resigned…,” but he added, “before I do that, it would be prudent to state that in his letter of resignation, Mr Makwakwa has indicated that he is resigning for personal reasons. He regards this as being an opportune moment for him to exit SARS after being cleared of all the allegations of impropriety against him.” Moyane said Makwakwa had made his personal tax information available to Parliament for scrutiny “and for public accountability”.

Moyane said last week: “As a result of lack of assistance from the FIC‚ during September 2016‚ SARS proceeded to suspend Makwakwa on the basis of the allegations contained in the FIC report. During October 2016‚ SARS appointed Hogan Lovells to conduct an investigation into allegations of impropriety against Mr Makwakwa. Hogan Lovells were also instructed to appoint Price Water Cooper (“PWC”) to assist with the investigation and in particular with regard to an analysis and audit of evidence of Mr Makwakwa’s financial affairs.”

Advocate SC Terry Motau
Advocate SC Terry Motau

Further‚ the investigation report recommended that the aspects of the investigation pertaining to money laundering and corruption be fully investigated by the Hawks as an authorised authority with the necessary capability. Moyane said: “It is a matter of public knowledge that Mr Makwakwa was cleared of all the charges at the disciplinary proceedings chaired by Adv. Terry Motau SC. The investigation into corruption and money laundering is ongoing and the SARS is co-operating with the DPCI (Hawks).”

Moyane said Makwakwa’s tax records would be made available to the standing committee on finance of parliament as would the Hogan Lovells report – which incorporates the report by the PWC.

Moyane last week also said: “As I understand the allegations‚ on 13 and 14 March 2018‚ the media widely reported that Makwakwa irregularly participated in the tender adjudication and appointment of NICS by SARS‚ notwithstanding the ongoing criminal investigation by the DPCI into allegations of corruption and money laundering involving Makwakwa and NICS together with other entities in respect of payment of over R400 000 (Four Hundred Thousand Rand)‚ paid to Mr Makwakwa. These allegations are currently being investigated by the DPCI on the basis of the FIC report of May 2016.”

“As I understand the allegations‚ Makwakwa was conflicted as he failed to declare a potential conflict of interest‚ acted dishonestly‚ failed to act fairly and failed to recuse himself from the adjudication as the circumstances duly required,” Moyane finally acknowledged.

Moyane reported that an investigation “will proceed to probe the allegations of irregularity surrounding the appointment of NICS. The matter will also be referred to the DPCI for criminal investigation”.

But Moyane added: “As the Commissioner‚ I would be negligent if I did not admit that the incidents surrounding the issues on Mr Makwakwa have taught us valuable lessons. I am sure there are areas that we could improve on and could have handled better.”

President Ramaphosa’s office said an acting SARS commissioner would be announced by the Minister of Finance Nhlanhla Nene.

SARS Media Release 

Pretoria, 19 March 2018 – The South African Revenue Service (SARS) wishes to express its deep concern and disturbance at the ongoing media onslaught that threatens to undermine the integrity of the organization.

SARS wishes to acknowledge that the media is an important institution that plays a pivotal role in our society. In fact, the average citizen, especially taxpayers, rely on its portrayal of SARS for fair and balanced views.

But SARS has observed and witnessed an unrelenting media attack that is skewed to project a misleading and unsubstantiated tone that is aimed at denting the reputation of the organization.

The latest assault focused all its venom on the SARS Commissioner Mr Tom Moyane by accusing him of illegally authorizing a VAT payment amounting to R70m to a taxpayer, despite ample proof that he had no role in the payment and had acted within the law.

SARS is concerned that this negative media campaign deliberately undermines significant successes and other achievement that reveal that the organization is solid, focused and efficient in carrying out its mandate. Some of these achievements include:

  • Reaching the historic R1-trillion mark in three years, including the current year;
  • R187,5 billion of high risk and possible fraudulent refunds for the past three years that SARS which could have been lost to the fiscus, with more than R28-billion of this prevented in the current financial year;
  • GDP ratio of almost 27% in difficult economic conditions, the success of which was  last achieved before the 2008/ 09 recession;
  • The restructuring that has seen historically disadvantaged individual, especially African, rise to the highest levels of the organization;
  • R2.7 billion revenue already collected under the Special Voluntary Disclosure Programme (SVDP);
  • More than R205-billion paid in refunds across all tax types in the past 10 and a half months;
  • Customs busts of illicit goods worth over R400-million since 1 January 2018;
  • For the period April 2017 – January 2018, the numbers of busts of the following prohibited/ restricted goods increased compared to the same time last year which include clothing and textiles by 144% and Illicit tobacco by 14.6%;
  • Over 55 Customs clients enjoying special benefits after being awarded Preferred Trader status since May 2017.

SARS respects media freedom and its role in holding office-bearers and public servants to account. Furthermore, the appreciation extends to the contribution of the media in exposing acts of criminality and corruption. SARS however, humbly requests balanced reporting and fairness.

SARS was pleased and has welcomed His Excellency, President Ramaphosa during his State of the Nation addresswhere committed to ‘Shortly appoint a Commission of Inquiry into Tax Administration and Governance of SARS’.

It is to that end that SARS believes all this malicious and untruthful allegation will be better ventilated and dispelled at the envisaged inquiry.  It is to this end that SARS humbly impresses on the President to find time in his busy schedule to finalize the details of the said inquiry.

It is only through such a thorough and transparent process that the true facts regarding SARS will be established and all media manufactured narratives will be exposed.

  • Donwald Pressly is the editor of Cape Messenger.
(Visited 40 times, 1 visits today)