President Jacob Zuma has nailed his colours to the mast. South Africa’s leader has highlighted his intentions to shake up the country’s commercial banking sector in the name of racial transformation on national television. But, with widespread allegations of state capture and the problems his friends, the Guptas, have been having in securing banking services, it is hard not to be cynical about his true motives. In an SABC interview on a show sponsored by Gupta-owned The New Age, Zuma slammed South Africa’s top four banks, Fin24 reports. Zuma accused banks of controlling the economy for the benefit of a few. Banks have been tied up in legal battles in connection with Gupta entities, which have been flagged up in connection with suspicious financial transactions. The Gupta family failed to persuade finance minister Pravin Gordhan to intervene on their behalf; now it seems they have none other than the president himself shamelessly doing their dirty work. Zuma’s comments on television are another indicator that the Guptas, not the ANC, are in charge. The big banks are listed on the JSE, with shareholders drawn from the usual diverse pool – pension funds to individual investors, including significant ownership in black hands. Zuma’s comments are simply not true. Nevertheless, they are likely to unsettle investors and further erode confidence in the country’s economic future. – Jackie Cameron
By Matthew le Cordeur & Liesl Peyper
Cape Town – President Jacob Zuma on Friday blamed South Africa’s top four banks for controlling the economy, hours after his State of the Nation Address (SONA) in Parliament.
“If you have got four banks – major ones – and they take everything; they don’t want you to do anything,” he said on SABC’s Morning Live, which is sponsored by Gupta-owned newspaper, The New Age.
Zuma said banks often treated poor black people unfairly due to their lack of collateral. “The time has come: we should be able to deal with the economy at a fair level,” he said.
The top four banks are Absa, Standard Bank, FNB and Nedbank.
“We actually frustrate our economy deliberately by making only a few people control the economy,” he said.
“I am told by those who do business that at times they even take your ideas and implement them because they have got the money.
“At the heart of the economy is finance,” he said. “If the… critical banks that dominate everything are just four… in all countries where the economy is developed, the banks are all over because it is the finances that make the economy grow.
“We want to change this,” he said. “If you have four banks, let us have more banks. Let us share that. Let us unpack the economy and give opportunities to everyone.
Instead of the populist rhetoric aimed at the banks #Zuma should address the zero economic growth and increased poverty created on his watch
— Joburg lawyer (@joburglawyer) January 23, 2017
“There’s a skewed kind of economic control,” he said. “We say that we must be part of owning, managing and be part of controlling the economy.
“You can’t have somebody who is super rich and have somebody who is super hungry in one country,” he said.
“As a government, we have a responsibility if we are to have the harmony, if we are to have the reconciliation. We should close the gap, not create a situation where others are going to be poor or that we change this.”
The vision for a much stronger state-controlled South African economy took centre stage in Zuma’s 2017 SONA.
The most controversial plan was perhaps Zuma’s mention of new draft legislation that will target the highly concentrated areas of the economy.
Although Zuma didn’t go into detail, it can be assumed he meant South Africa’s financial services sector, which will soon be the subject of a round of public hearings in Parliament where a number of stakeholders will provide input on how they see the sector being transformed.
A gent stands up at the Gupta-sponsored breakfast to thank Zuma for "one of the best *budget* speeches". Gupta speechwriters are failing.
— Mabine Seabe II (@Mabine_Seabe) February 10, 2017
The proposed legislation, which Zuma said would help “de-concentrate” certain sectors, will be drafted by the Department of Economic Development and will soon make its way to Cabinet and Parliament for deliberation.
A recommendation in September 2016 by Zuma’s inter-ministerial committee that looked into the top four banks’ decision to blacklist Gupta-owned companies was released erroneously as a done deal by Mineral Resources Minister Mosebenzi Zwane last year. While Zuma rebuked Zwane for the release of the recommendation (saying it was not sanctioned), the banking sector was able to see what might be coming their way.
Zwane said a judicial inquiry should look into the establishment of a state bank of South Africa with the possible corporatisation of the Postbank being considered as an option.
“Evidence presented to the IMC (inter-ministerial committee) suggested that all of South Africa’s economic power vests in the hands of very specific institutions, institutions who have shown that their ability to act unilaterally is within their mandate and is protected,” said Zwane. “These institutions are owned by private shareholders and report to National Treasury who in turn do not need to act on information provided to it.”
Fin24 reported on January 31 2017 that the South African Post Office (Sapo) is expected to submit an application to have its financial services unit registered as a bank by mid-2017.
Sapo will submit an application to register Postbank as a bank by July 3, a document handed out in Parliament showed in January.
Sapo CEO Mark Barnes said the Post Office has R2.7bn in capital, and retained earnings at the end of December 2016 sufficient to meet the regulatory requirements.
In July last year, the South African Reserve Bank approved Sapo’s first-level application for a banking licence for Postbank. – Fin24
South Africa’s Zuma Says Big Four Banks’ Dominance Must End
(Bloomberg) — South African President Jacob Zuma said the dominance of the country’s four major banks must end and access to the economy for the black majority improved.“There’s a skewed kind of economic control,” Zuma said on Friday. “We actually frustrate our economy deliberately by letting a few people control the economy. So we want to change that. Let us have more banks and share that space.”
The country’s five largest lenders, including the so-called Big Four of Standard Bank Group Ltd., Barclays Africa Group Ltd., FirstRand Ltd. and Nedbank Group Ltd., control about 90 percent of banking assets in the country. Criticism of the lenders from Zuma and his supporters intensified after the institutions refused to do business with companies linked to the Gupta family, who are friends with the president and in business with his son.
Zuma, 74, was speaking at an event hosted by The New Age newspaper, which has ties to the Guptas. The family, led by brothers Atul, Ajay and Rajesh, came to South Africa from India in 1993 and built a business group ranging from computers to uranium mining. His comments follow the state-of-the-nation address on Thursday, in which he said the inclusion of the black majority in the economy has been too slow.
The monopoly in the mining sector should also be addressed, Zuma said, while increasing land ownership for black people discriminated against during apartheid also formed part of the government’s plan to transform the economy.
“Let us not have others having the monopoly and others having nothing,” he said. “If we don’t do it as a country, we are sitting with a time bomb.”
Barclays Africa, controlled by the U.K.’s Barclays Plc, was the target of the ruling African National Congress’ Youth League on Friday. Protesters, who marched to the bank’s Johannesburg headquarters, demanded it pay back money from a bailout provided to a lender it bought before the end of apartheid. This comes after the leaking of a draft report compiled by South Africa’s graft ombudsman that said Barclays Africa, which traded as Absa then, may have unduly benefited from state support when it bought Bankorp in 1992.
Amid Zuma’s statements and the Youth League’s ire, the six-member banks index rose the most this year, climbing 2 percent as of 3:07 p.m. in Johannesburg in its biggest move since Dec. 29. RMB Holdings Ltd. and Nedbank led the gains while Barclays Africa rose the least, climbing 1.3 percent to 161.05 rand.