Exposé – SA’s water scarcity set to match electricity woes

CAPE TOWN — South Africans are increasingly being faced with the prospect of being unable to rely on any tier of government for water and electricity, something many comparable economies take for granted. We’re almost the antithesis of Brazil which has the world’s largest water storage capacity, with hydroelectricity generation meeting over 70% of its electricity demand. Brazil’s national grid is 80% from renewable sources. You could say they’re blessed, but then so are we with adequate rivers, coal and plentiful sun, not to mention wind. It’s how we’ve used our resources – and more to the point – how increasingly dysfunctional their management has become over the past nearly three decades. South Africa is warming at twice the global average, according to the Department of Environmental Affairs. Our water reserve allocation was 98% a full 16 years ago. Leaks in corrupt, service and maintenance-inept municipalities waste up to 40% of this most precious resource. This story provides striking examples pointing to a national crisis right up there with Eskom. The nagging existential question is, must we start engaging in pragmatic ‘survivalist’ thinking, or believe that our political system, as currently set-up, can help us fix things? Story courtesy of The Daily Maverick. – Chris Bateman

By Rebecca Davis

“There were jubilant shouts of ‘amanzi’ (water), with faces beaming in disbelief as people ran towards our trucks entering Grahamstown. Nine days of no water, nine days of desperation. The crowds, including many university students, gathered outside the municipality eagerly awaiting whatever they could get.”

This statement, released by emergency aid group Gift of the Givers on Wednesday, reads like a scene from a post-apocalyptic novel.

Yet its reflection of the situation in Makhanda (formerly Grahamstown) is essentially “accurate”, according to local newspaper Grocott’s Mail editor Sue Maclennan.

The spiralling municipal breakdown of Makhanda has left many residents without water for more than a week. Reports have painted a picture of a town in the throes of decay. A widely-shared tweet by DA MP Belinda Bozzoli showed a photograph of a dead donkey on a town pavement, captioned by Bozzoli:

“This once beautiful little university town has been reduced over the years to a slum, with sewerage, piles of rubbish and even a dead donkey in the streets.”

The Department of Water and Sanitation did not respond to Daily Maverick’s request for comment on Wednesday. Earlier this week, however, spokesperson Sputnik Ratau was quoted by News24 as saying that it was not the department’s responsibility to deliver emergency water supplies to towns in crisis, such as Makhanda.

“It is our responsibility to say to a municipality that you cannot allow that thing to happen,” Ratau was quoted as saying.

Enter the charity, Gift of the Givers, which has come to the aid of other South African towns in similar water-strapped states, including Beaufort West in the Western Cape. As it has done elsewhere, the group dispensed bottles of water and drilled boreholes. Gift of the Givers leader, Dr Imtiaz Sooliman, said in a statement that the group has drilled 200 boreholes within an eight-month period.

“There are many grateful people in this town today,” Maclennan told Daily Maverick.

“While some were critical, saying water tanks would have been a better way to spend the money, even 10 litres of drinkable water after eight days of dry taps makes a difference to a family — and we all re-use the 5-litre bottles.”

Makhanda’s current crisis represents the culmination of what happens when municipal and governmental mismanagement collides with drought — and it is a picture playing out in different areas across the country.

The Western Cape government announced this week that Beaufort West received 0mm of rain in December and 2mm of rain in January — as compared with its usual average December rainfall of 28mm and January rainfall of 20mm.

Compounding the situation in the town is the age-riddled and asset-stripped water infrastructure.

“In Beaufort West, leaks are estimated to see 40% of water waste away,” Western Cape local government spokesperson James-Brent Styan told Daily Maverick.

Styan says that other water-starved areas in the Western Cape include Kannaland, which encompasses Calitzdorp, Zoar and Ladismith, and Laingsburg.

“The real disaster is in the agricultural sector,” said Styan.

Another Western Cape official put it more bluntly: The agricultural sector is “completely buggered”.

To the list of water-critical areas, Water Shortage SA CEO Benoit le Roy adds Mathjabeng and Harrismith in the Free State and Bethal and surrounds in Mpumalanga.

“These are, in my opinion, merely symptoms, not unlike Eskom, of the onset of total collapse of water infrastructure in SA,” Le Roy told Daily Maverick.

In May 2018, the Department of Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs classified 87 municipalities — 31% of the country’s total — as “dysfunctional or distressed”, a diagnosis which almost always makes itself felt in problems with the municipal water supply.

Le Roy rattles off a list of causes of the country’s water problems, ranging from a lack of leadership in the notoriously poorly performing Department of Water and Sanitation to “cadre deployment in local municipalities where the management of water budgets, resources and assets is dysfunctional”.

In Le Roy’s view, South Africa’s water situation is “far more serious” than its Eskom-instigated energy woes.

“Our water reserve was officially declared 98% allocated in 2002. This means that no new water is practically available. We are water-scarce in the entirety (of) South Africa,” he says.

Since the beginning of February 2019 alone, the Department of Water and Sanitation has issued statements warning citizens to curtail water usage in the Eastern Cape, North West, Mpumalanga and Gauteng, largely as a result of dropping dam volumes. Worryingly, most of South Africa’s annual rainfall occurs during the summer months.

As Daily Maverick’s Kevin Bloom noted in a recent critique of the government’s gas exploration plans, the Department of Environmental Affairs has previously stated that South Africa is warming at twice the global average.

“We are going to see these kinds of droughts more frequently, for sure,” says Styan. “We need to plan better. It’s now about building resilient communities.”

In 2015, however, Parliament heard that upgrading South Africa’s water and sanitation sector to ensure the necessary water resilience was likely to cost about R870bn.

Le Roy’s organisation, Water Shortage SA, has recently teamed up with the Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (Outa) to call for an independent water regulator to exert some measure of oversight on the problem.

“The Department of Water and Sanitation’s failure to effectively regulate South Africa’s water sector requires serious and effective intervention,” the two groups said.

“The establishment of an independent water regulator — like the National Energy Regulator for South Africa (Nersa) in the energy sector — is long overdue.”

Le Roy says this body would be the first step towards “reinstating governance in the water sector”. Thereafter, a new workable national water strategic plan should be drafted and implemented, and the relevant experts appointed within all three spheres of government.

“Without these three steps we cannot arrest the implosion of SA’s water resources,” Le Roy warns.

“Even a fixed Eskom will be immaterial — as, without water, our economy is not able to attract investment.” DM