Zero-income Eskom between a rock and a dark place – no easy fix

CAPE TOWN — This candle-lit journey down a dark Eskom memory lane exposes several pot-holed cul-de-sacs that a series of dysfunctional (and more latterly, crooked) managements navigated woefully badly. So dismally that Eskom today stands to decimate our fragile economy. Treasury is caught in a Catch 22 situation – trickle feed them R100bn or so (a mere quarter of the Eskom debt needing servicing) or risk crippling the fiscus and further denuding other public services with a lump sum bail-out. Either way the economy is at severe risk. The embattled ANC is hardly likely to take on the powerful unions with layoffs and risk being forced into a coalition government at the May polls next year. Eskom’s board and political management are a case history in being so penny-wise and pound foolish that by the time they realised extra power generation infrastructure was needed it was too late. It’s now proving massively costly. So, they continue to cut corners, lurching on and hoping the best brains other people’s money can buy will keep the lights on and factories running. South Africans no longer take anything for granted. If the trip-switch stays down, it’ll be every man and woman for themselves. – Chris Bateman

By Mike Cohen and Paul Burkhardt

(Bloomberg) – It’s deja vu for South Africa as a chronic power deficit plunges large tracts of the country into darkness and casts a pall over the already struggling economy.

Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd., which supplies most of the nation’s electricity, has instituted daily rolling blackouts since Nov. 29 to avert a total collapse of the grid – as it did in 2008 and 2015. Outages are set to persist for at least several months as the state utility’s new management contends with maintenance backlogs, construction delays and coal shortages.

An electricity pylon stands beyond an Eskom sign at the entrance to the Grootvlei power station. Photographer: Dean Hutton/Bloomberg

Eskom is also afflicted by deep structural and financial problems. It’s racked up R419bn ($30.6bn) in debt that it’s battling to service, and it isn’t selling enough power to cover its costs. While it anticipates a loss of more than R11.2bn in the 12 months through March, its ability to fire thousands of surplus workers is constrained by militant unions and a government that’s gearing up to contest elections next year.

The utility, which has depended on state guarantees and bailouts for years to operate and borrow, has warned it may need more help to survive – money President Cyril Ramaphosa’s administration can ill afford. The company will propose the state absorbs R100bn of its debt as part of a turnaround plan, Business Day reported, citing Eskom Chairman Jabu Mabuza.

Here’s how the crisis at Eskom has unfolded

Founded in 1923 and known as the Electricity Supply Commission before changing its name to Eskom in 1987, the utility built dozens of mainly coal-fired plants over six decades to become the world’s fourth-largest power company. While it had considerable excess capacity by the time white-minority rule ended in 1994, that was steadily eroded as neglected black townships gained access to electricity and economy growth accelerated.

Although the energy department warned of pending power shortages in 1998, adding to generating capacity was low on the government’s list of priorities. After the government eventually recognised the looming energy crunch in late 2004, Eskom announced a series of multi-billion rand investments, including the construction of the massive Medupi and Kusile coal-fired plants.

The investments came too late. Some areas were struck by power cuts in late 2005 and 2006, countrywide rolling blackouts began in October 2007 and a national electricity emergency was declared in January 2008 as the grid neared collapse, shutting most mines and factories for five days.

World Cup

Blackouts were suspended in February 2008 as Eskom brought idled plants’ units back into service and delayed maintenance to ensure the lights stayed on in the run-up to the 2010 soccer World Cup. But the lack of upkeep took its toll on its facilities, with outages resuming in 2014 and intensifying the following year.

In mid-2015, the government named Brian Molefe as Eskom’s chief executive officer, the sixth person to occupy the post within a decade. He’d headed the state pension fund manager and had been lauded for his running of state logistics company Transnet SOC Ltd.

The utility seemed to have turned a corner as Molefe set about tackling the maintenance backlog and delays in the construction of Medupi and Kusile, and several other plants came online. A limping economy eased pressure on the power supply.

The honeymoon was short-lived. Molefe quit in late 2016 after the nation’s anti-graft ombudsman accused him of favouring members of the Gupta family, who were in business with then-President Jacob Zuma’s son, in handing out coal-supply contracts. Molefe, the Guptas, Zuma and his son all denied wrongdoing.

Mismanagement scandals

The government scuppered an attempt by Eskom’s board to reappoint Molefe to his post in May 2017, but the company continued to lurch from one graft and mismanagement scandal to the next under a succession of three acting CEOs.

In December, Ramaphosa replaced Zuma as head of the ruling party, and the following month a new board was appointed to rehabilitate the utility. Phakamani Hadebe, a former head of the Land and Agricultural Development Bank of South Africa, was named CEO and Jabu Mabuza chairman, a post he also holds at telecommunications company Telkom SA.

The new management has moved to stamp out corruption. At least 14 senior executives and 99 other employees implicated in wrongdoing have left the company, and scores of others have been sanctioned, while 12 criminal cases have been opened.

Wage freeze

Less headway has been made in putting the company on a sustainable footing. Labour unions and the government derailed the company’s attempt to freeze the wages of its almost 50,000 employees. Eskom eventually agreed to pay increases of 23% over three years and a bonus to end a series of illegal protests.

The company has also failed to pin down sufficient coal supplies, and a shortage of funds and skilled personnel have resulted in maintenance on its aging fleet slipping behind schedule – both of which have made power cuts unavoidable.

Medupi and Kusile, which were supposed to be fully operational in 2015, are still years away from completion, with their projected costs more than doubling to R292.5bn.

Eskom has hired Boston Consulting Group to develop a long-term strategic plan and Lazard Ltd. to provide financial advisory services. Just how they envision the utility digging itself out of the hole it’s in remains unclear, but one thing is certain: there are no easy answers.